Personal Capital (Empower) vs Clarity
| Feature | Empower | Clarity |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing (Basic Tools) | Free | $99/year |
| Wealth Management Fees | 0.49-0.89% AUM (on $100K+ portfolios) | None |
| Primary Focus | Investment management + advisory | Budgeting + transaction tracking |
| Crypto Support | ||
| Recurring Subscription Detection | Manual tracking | Automatic detection |
| Budgeting Tools | Basic (not primary feature) | Full category budgets with rollover |
| Transaction Categorization | Automatic | Automatic with AI |
| Investment Tracking | Advanced (portfolio analysis, allocation) | Basic (holdings + balances) |
| Retirement Planner | Yes (detailed) | |
| Fee Analyzer | Yes (investment fees) | No |
| Data Privacy | Tied to wealth management services | Your data stays yours (no advisory) |
| Mobile App | iOS + Android | Web + iOS |
| Cost Basis Tracking (Crypto) | FIFO method included | |
| Upsells | Constant (wealth management, advisors) | None |
What Happened to Personal Capital?
Personal Capital was acquired by Empower Retirement in 2020 for $1 billion. The app rebranded to Empower and shifted focus:
- Old Focus: Free financial dashboard with optional wealth management
- New Focus: Wealth management + advisory services (0.49-0.89% AUM fees)
- Free Tools Still Available: Net worth tracking, cash flow, investment analysis
- Aggressive Upsells: Persistent calls/emails to convert to paid wealth management
If you just want budgeting, transaction tracking, and daily money management — Empower constantly pushes advisory services you don't need.
Why Clarity is the Better Fit for Budgeters
Empower is great if you have $100K+ to invest and want professional portfolio management. Clarity is for people who need daily money tracking, budgeting, and crypto support.
1. No Wealth Management Upsells
Empower's free tools exist to convert you into a wealth management client. Their revenue model is 0.49-0.89% AUM fees. On a $500K portfolio, that's $2,450-4,450/year.
Clarity's approach: We're a budgeting tool, not wealth management. You pay $99/year for transaction tracking, budgets, and crypto support. No upsells. No advisor calls.
2. Crypto Support
Empower (like most traditional finance apps) doesn't support crypto. If you own Bitcoin, Ethereum, or any blockchain assets, your net worth is incomplete.
Clarity's approach: Connect exchanges (Coinbase, Kraken, Binance) and blockchain wallets. See TradFi + crypto in one dashboard. FIFO cost basis for tax reporting.
3. Better Budgeting Tools
Empower has budgeting features, but they're secondary to investment tracking. The UI prioritizes portfolio analysis, not daily spending.
Clarity's approach: Budgeting is our core feature. Category budgets with rollover, automatic recurring detection, merchant normalization. Designed for people who want to control spending, not just track investments.
4. Automatic Recurring Detection (Not Manual Tags)
Empower shows subscriptions if you manually categorize them. Most people don't, so hidden subscriptions drain accounts silently.
Clarity's approach: We analyze frequency, amount consistency, and merchant patterns. You see every subscription, even ones you forgot about.
When to Use Empower vs Clarity
Use Empower if...
- You have $100K+ to invest
- You want professional wealth management
- You need retirement planning tools
- You want investment fee analysis
- You're OK with 0.49-0.89% AUM fees
- You don't own crypto
Use Clarity if...
- You want budgeting (not wealth management)
- You own any crypto (any amount)
- You hate upsells and advisor calls
- You need recurring subscription detection
- You want TradFi + crypto in one place
- You prefer flat $99/year pricing
Migrating from Personal Capital to Clarity
If you're using Empower's free tools but don't want wealth management, switching to Clarity takes 10 minutes:
- Sign up for Clarity's 14-day trial (no credit card required)
- Connect your banks via Plaid (same provider Empower uses)
- Add crypto exchanges/wallets (if you have any)
- Set category budgets (Clarity auto-suggests based on spending)
- Review transactions — Clarity learns your patterns
- Check net worth (TradFi + crypto combined)
You can keep using Empower for investment tracking if you like their portfolio tools. Clarity complements it with better budgeting + crypto.
Pricing Breakdown: $99/year vs 0.49-0.89% AUM
Empower's Free Tools: Net worth, cash flow, investment tracking, retirement planner (free)
Empower's Wealth Management: 0.49-0.89% AUM (minimum $100K portfolio)
- $100K portfolio = $490-890/year
- $500K portfolio = $2,450-4,450/year
- $1M portfolio = $4,900-8,900/year
Clarity's Pricing: $99/year flat (no AUM fees, no minimums)
- Budgeting + transaction tracking
- Banks + crypto support
- Recurring detection
- Cost basis tracking (crypto)
- No upsells, no advisor calls
If you don't need wealth management, Clarity is $99/year vs Empower's constant upsell pressure.
What Clarity Doesn't Do (Yet)
Clarity is focused on budgeting + crypto. We deliberately skip features Empower has:
- Wealth Management: No advisors, no portfolio rebalancing services
- Retirement Planner: Not available (not our focus)
- Fee Analyzer: Empower's investment fee breakdown tool (not our focus)
- Android App: Not available (web + iOS only)
If you need those features, Empower's free tools are great. If you just want budgeting + crypto, Clarity is the better fit.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happened to Personal Capital?
Personal Capital was acquired by Empower Retirement in 2020 for $1 billion and rebranded to Empower. The free financial tools still exist, but the company now focuses on wealth management advisory services with 0.49-0.89% AUM fees.
Is Empower's free dashboard still good?
The free tools (net worth, cash flow, investment analysis) still work, but the experience is increasingly focused on converting you to a paid wealth management client. Expect persistent calls and emails from advisors after signing up.
Does Clarity offer wealth management?
No. Clarity is a budgeting and finance tracking tool, not a wealth management service. If you need professional portfolio management, Empower is the better choice. If you just want budgeting + crypto tracking without upsells, choose Clarity.
Can I use both Empower and Clarity?
Yes. Some users keep Empower for its investment analysis tools (fee analyzer, retirement planner) and use Clarity for daily budgeting and crypto tracking. The two complement each other well.
Compare Clarity to other apps